Mediocrity

May 27, 2026 | 5 comments


Mediocrity

A few months ago I wrote an essay titled, A Year’s Worth of Me noting the one-year anniversary of writing these weekly pieces. In that offering I discussed the weight I’ve felt with regard to being told at a very early age that I was not meeting my potential. I have carried that critique of the three-year-old me for my entire life, feeling that somehow I have missed the opportunity to meet some subjective notion of potential. But there is an equally debilitating word that has haunted me for almost as long. It is the term: MEDIOCRITY. Potential and Mediocrity are closely related for it seems if one is going to achieve something of substance, then that achievement is going to go beyond mediocrity to set a standard well above the average.

On the other hand, I’ve often wondered if it is even possible, regardless of what I accomplish in life, to slough off the cloud of self-doubt that has always hovered over my psyche, keeping me from feeling that I have achieved anything of value within the goals life has dangled in front of me. I know this sounds a bit like self-pity (wah-wah), but feelings are difficult to erase despite a desire to embrace a more pragmatic perspective of myself.

What I do know is that regardless of outcome, I attempt to do the best I can at whatever I’m engaged in at the moment though I rarely, if ever, reach beyond a sense of being mired in mediocrity. On occasion it feels like I might achieve a grade of B+ which, in the great scheme of things, is pretty good. Others may disagree, suggesting I’m too hard on myself. That may be the case as well, but from inside the hard-shell casing of my subjective self-perception, it’s very difficult to unearth a greater degree of objectivity.

At least to me, climbing out of Mediocrity is not measured by financial success. Just because someone might be good (or lucky) at acquiring wealth does not mean they aren’t stuck waist deep in a mediocre life. When I look at the lives of people like Elon Musk (one of my favorite targets) or Larry Elison, Mark Zuckerberg, Peter Thiel, Donald Trump, and thousands of other multi-billionaires, I see a class of people who are living a mediocre life (at best). Building of a better world entails moving beyond mediocrity and that takes compassion, intelligence, kindness, and empathy, which these people do not have.

Unfortunately only a few exceptions exist. Mackenzie Scott, Melinda Gates, Warren Buffet, to name a few, are people who see and understand the world from a very different point of view and are living life to the fullest by making a positive impact. There are also a great number of people who have found a fulfilled life near the apex of well-being and inner peace and yet have next to no money. These folks are much richer in the things that matter than the egocentric uber-wealthy mentioned above.

BUT, with all of that said, I admit that I pass judgement daily on a portion of humanity based on their actions and behavior as decidedly mediocre. As noted above I strive for a higher level of quality in almost everything I try to do, so I find it difficult to understand why everyone doesn’t want to do their best as well. Even if a person fails, the desire, the dream of accomplishment, is worth the effort. With that said, it’s important to mention there are many, many people who are doing a wonderful job and who are throwing themselves into their work, producing excellent results.

There are a number of industries where a lackluster attitude is most evident. The restaurant business for instance is rife with C+ mediocre quality meals. When I eat out and the food is basically “Meh” at best, it makes no sense to me. As someone who likes to cook, I know that it’s relatively easy to make good food though I admit when one gets into the realm of high-end preparation, the expertise needed is well above my skill level. But to prepare a basic, good tasting meal is not that difficult. As an example, just down the road from our home there is a breakfast and lunch diner, open from 7am to 3pm, seven days a week. The food is consistently extremely well prepared. The owner, the staff, and the kitchen crew care about creating dishes that are not just edible, but really quite good. As the old saying goes, “This is not rocket science!” And yet this is the exception and not the rule.

Instead, perhaps I should be looking to the patrons who frequent mediocre establishments. That they are willing to put up with and pay for run-of-the-mill food and service sends a message that this level of quality is acceptable. But even with that, where is the pride of work where someone is creating a product they feel great about? Is it just a job, so who cares? If the general public doesn’t care, why should the person engaged in that job even care? What I keep coming back to is that doing a great job feels good. That by going above and beyond, the person working feels they have stepped out of the shadow of mediocrity.

I’m also reminded of the American auto industry that for decades manufactured low quality vehicles even though they had the ability and technology to produce a higher-grade car. It wasn’t until companies in Asia such as Honda, Toyota, Hyundai, and Kia began exporting longer lasting and better made autos that the big three took notice and tried to play catch up. It was the bottom line of making more money and the unwillingness of the public to demand higher quality that allowed Ford, GM, and Chrysler to continue along the path of mediocrity.

I’ve only touched on the surface of this issue. This propensity to be stuck in a mindset of mediocrity remains rampant in many parts of the world, including right here in our nation that once led the world in innovation, quality, and pride of production. Did we just become lazy? Or did we just lower our expectations of each other?

In the meantime, I will continue to do my best to reach above that B+ level though at this advanced age, it may be a silly endeavor. I sometimes wonder if I would just be happier if I lowered my own expectations of myself. But I highly doubt if that’s going to change at this point. I suspect I will continue to feel compelled to keep trying regardless. There are times you just have to go with what you know.

To end this week’s offering I’ve added a piece written about 12 years ago expressing my fairly vehement frustration with regard to this subject. As always, please feel free to comment.

A Cynic’s Soliloquy

Streets spill over with hollow-eyed
mumblers who walk as if alive.
Their transfat hearts thudding in
rib lined cavities as their lungs fill with
calcified remnants of self-serving piety.
Turgid animals wallowing through
their own nightmares where the dream
of satiated greed collides head-on with
the mumbo jumbo of manifest destiny;
where truth is found on a cereal box
and facts, like scraps of dust,
are swept under the nearest Persian carpet.

Creatures who roam this floating, spinning orb
as if tomorrow existed in a tin can
to be opened just prior to the expiration date.
Travesty abounds for they have allowed the curiosity
that could have made them great to be sucked out
through their collective noses by tabloid aliens
or by hodgepodge conspiracies manufactured
out of fabricated paranoid fantasies.

Who the hell are these heffalumping bipeds,
the ones who sweat the blood of others and then,
thinking they are so clever, piss into the wind?
Who would have guessed, for as Pogo the ‘Possum
quipped those many years ago,
“We have met the enemy and he is us.”

Yes, them is us. The very same foot-shooting, lemming-esk,
self-aggrandizing, gluttons for irony, who ooze from TV ads
for quality American cars.  The very same ones who stare
back from the mirrors of narcissism,
found in the glassed skyscrapers we have erected
as monuments to ourselves.

We are God’s April Fool’s joke on himself;
the ones running full tilt,
with our white canes tucked neatly under our arms,
towards the end of days.

 

5 Comments

  1. Jody Burns

    Your work with carousels is top of the game–not a whiff of mediocrity in that effort. Give yourself credit for contributing in the highest way to the American carousel tradition.

    Reply
    • Tobin Fraley

      Jody – Thank you but as I told another friend, so much of life is directly impacted by our expectations of ourselves. This is particularly relevant with regard to my personal perception of my own achievements relative to my sense of accomplishment. I firmly believe most of what we do is illusory. Sounds bleak, but look at the world today within the context of all of the wise and wonderful people over thousands of years who have done so much to further the beneficial aspects of our species and yet . . .

      Reply
  2. Jerry King

    Tobin I related to your essay. Indeed it is as if we are dragged along by judgments, the pronouncements inscribed by authority figures, when we were essentially helpless, without recourse to any critical faculties of self-reflection. No doubt that is the story of what has happened to all of us, since the very beginnings. Wounded, damaged adults impose upon the young, inherited self depreciation, a constricted bitterness about their prospects.

    To this day remember my grandmother (who raised me) making a rhetorical statement to my father, referring to me. “Roy, do you think he will amount to anything?” I do not recall that my father had any reply. And so it goes.

    Aside from the subsurface baggage, it is a good thing to strive, to enjoy, to respect excellence. You only need to enter the sculpture hall at the Louvre to be rendered speechless at the Roman copies of Greek statuary. Excellence is human, the apex of expression for us homo sapiens. As you noted in the paragraph beginning with a capitalized “BUT” – the desire, the dream of accomplishment is worth the effort. I could not agree more!

    You lament a generalized acceptance of mediocrity among our fellow Americans. It seems to me this arises from the excessive metrification of nearly everything. Much of our urban American way of life has been standardized, routinized in order to fit into a capitalist model – we are massaged into a mediocre common denominator as per the requirements of Amazon, Facebook, etc., etc.. We’ve colluded to create a “dumbed down”, uncaring ethos. Excellence demands care.

    Not only do domestic automakers offer shoddy products by comparison to options from Japan, Korea – they have doubled down on manufacturing pickup trucks because the marketing has been so successful, with a subtext of toxic masculinity. The effort to offer well designed family vehicles has been left to foreign competitors.

    A final note about the Japanese bias for excellence. The history of Japan has been long, and for the most part subject to natural severity such as earthquakes, tsunamis, and the ebb and flow of feudal rule. Add to that the complex of Buddhist and Shinto influence that highlights the beauty and complexity of nature – you get a relentless quest for exquisite harmony, pursuit of perfection. That is what they know.

    We have to go with what you know, as you observed. We are always learning though. What one knows is always subject to qualification, by what we receive from others.

    We will carry on!

    Reply
    • Tobin Fraley

      Jerry – Excellent points. I really love your notes about the history of Japan and the striving for excellence. Personally I have always been drawn to the Japanese aesthetic so this makes a great deal of sense.

      We all have baggage to carry. I wish that it were simple to to open those bags and dispose of the contents, but these aspects of childhood experience have become ingrained in each of us, making it very difficult to extricate ourselves. We need to keep on reaching for a more objective perspective regardless of the difficulty in doing so.

      Thank you again my friend for your ongoing insights.

      Reply
  3. Verna Todd

    Oops. The more things change, the more they stay the same? (Yes, I’m still enjoying following you.)

    Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *